Immigration Update |
Department of Labor's Proposed PERM Overhaul
The Department of Labor published its proposal for PERM overhaul on November 17, 2026, with comments due on January 19, 2027. I offer some initial thoughts on the overhaul's proposed elimination of Schedule A and how it could undermine our workforce.
The Department of Labor published its proposal for PERM overhaul on November 17, 2026, with comments due on January 19, 2027. Most of the ensuing commentary has focused on the 90-day recruitment period (replacing 30 days) and the two-year layoff bar (replacing 6 months). However, the overhaul’s elimination of Schedule A, which currently allows for a more streamlined processing of immigrant visas for certain beneficiaries, entirely deserves more attention, and not only for the reason most practitioners assume.
Schedule A has two groups. Group I covers professional nurses and physical therapists. Group II covers individuals of exceptional ability in the sciences or arts, including the performing arts, added in 2004. Both would be gone if the proposed regulations take effect in their present form.
Group I is the loss being actively discussed. Nurses and physical therapists have been the only Schedule A occupations since the 1990s, and DOL now says it cannot justify waiving recruitment for them absent a current national shortage finding. My own view is that these shortages are well documented and widely acknowledged, so it is unclear why the DOL feels that the inclusion of these professions is unjustified.
But Group II is the quieter loss, and the reasoning behind it is different in kind. DOL states it would eliminate Group II, even if a workable shortage methodology existed, because Group II turns on an individual's qualifications rather than on an occupation. That rationale is independent of the shortage-methodology record the DOL relies on elsewhere. Curing the evidentiary gap on nurses and physical therapists would not save Group II.
My question to the DOL: do we not want more individuals of exceptional ability to join our workforce on a permanent basis? USCIS has no trouble adjudicating these petitions, so why make it more difficult for U.S. employers to retain them? The legal standard for meeting the “exceptional” criteria is high, and if an employer can meet it on behalf of a valued employee they wish to sponsor, everyone benefits.
For performing artists especially, the stakes are concrete. The Group II performing arts criteria at 20 CFR 656.15(d)(2) are meaningfully more attainable than the sciences and arts prongs, and I have relied on them for classical dancers and other performing artists whose careers do not map onto academic evidence of acclaim.
I would love to see Schedule A stay and even expand to additional occupations. If DOL proceeds, it should at minimum sever Group II from a shortage analysis that was never about occupations in the first place. Stakeholders, including universities, hospitals, and arts organizations, have until January 19, 2027, to say so on the record.
More here: https://www.federalregister.gov/d/2026-23370